Front Walking Granny Dog & Cat Costume

The try-on wall featured a handful of costumes but this one – THIS one – was the clear winner for me. We snatched one up and stuck it on my eager buddy, Jasper, who didn't even seem to mind the wig that comes with it. He scampered around the showroom proudly, wiggling and charming everyone who watched while clearly enjoying the attention.

Bring this costume home for your own little rascal and prepare for loads of laughs when they come trotting out to show off the granny goods. It's equally funny on cats, too!

Halloween Living Dead Monsters Plush Squeaky Dog Toy, 3 count

My dogs are all seniors now (one is even a super-senior), so it takes a lot for toys to excite them. However, they went wild the second I ripped these open.

They're the perfect size for small to medium mouths and soft without being easy to shred. I wouldn't hand this over to a particularly strong-jawed breed who can tear open a tennis ball, but for anyone with smaller pups who want something as cute to look at as it is pleasing to their pets? Laugh it up with these living dead charmers.

Frisco Bumble Guinea Pig Costume, One Size

Like most other things on this list, this is utterly ridiculous yet wholly necessary if you're a Halloween fanatic like me. My guinea pig is a pretty docile old guy, so I'm hopeful he'll enjoy this costume for a little while when we have guests over for our annual party.

Disney Hocus Pocus Ride-On Sanderson Sisters Dog & Cat Costume

My next favorite costume was this flying Sanderson sisters cape that no fan of Hocus Pocus can help but swoon over. The simple black top is a comfortable fit for dogs of any size, and the dolls are securely attached via their brooms, grinning widely and ready to charm. This is a great option for dogs who don't love a super ornate or binding costume, and it's sure to please kids of all ages who rewatch Salem's favorite film every year.

Halloween Voodoo Doll Plush Squeaky Dog Toy

Every time I caught myself saying, "This is the cutest toy I've seen so far," I realized there was no true way to name any one product that. But this one came close!

This larger-than-expected 15-inch doll is made of plush and burlap, with a sturdy finish that can stand up to some wear and tear. Its bewitching features make it tempting to use as seasonal home decor instead of simply a toy for Fido, but your dog will get too much joy for you to keep it all to yourself – unless you buy two, of course.

Front Walking Werewolf Dog & Cat Costume

True to character, this cat costume will have you howling. Your cat may or may not try to rip it off immediately, but it's well worth the photo op you get out of it when their face pokes through that wiry mane of werewolf fluff.

Halloween Haunted Shack Hide and Seek Puzzle Plush Squeaky Dog Toy

Do you ever look at something and think it's so cute, so enchanting, and so utterly delightful that you feel like you might pass out? That's how I felt (and still feel) when I look at this haunted house. It's great for dogs who need the mental stimulation of a puzzle game, and it will be the perfect amount of spooky season cheer to your home. Just look at that ghost peeking out of the window!

Disney Halloween Villains Snow White & the Evil Queen Hide & Seek Puzzle Plush Squeaky Dog Toy

Everything I said about the above haunted house toy qualifies here, too. Even the evil witch is charming beyond belief.

Halloween Magical Wardrobe Interactive Plush Cat Toy with Catnip, 3-count

If your cats are anything like mine, they need a source of near-constant stimulation to keep them from getting into mischief. This interactive toy provides exactly that and stimulates their senses with catnip and crinkle paper tucked inside the cozy material, offering hours of entertainment that helps them get their daily exercise and ward off the kitty cat blues.

Frisco Vampire Cape Dog & Cat Costume

As the owner of an all-black cat named Dracula, it was mandatory I buy this cape. He doesn't mind it and seems to even feel regal while wearing it, and putting it on him is a snap thanks to the velcro closure.

Temptations Creepy Catnip Blissful Catnip Flavor Cat Treats

My cats are already Temptations devotees, but I have never heard them howl quite so pathetically for any other treat in their lives. Make sure to stock up when you bring these home, because your feline is sure to get hooked on them.

Greenies Scary Berry Blueberry Flavor Teenie Dental Dog Treats, 6-oz bag

Canine dental health can be precarious, but delicious treats that help cut down on plaque like these Greenies are a great way to keep their pearly whites healthier longer. My three seniors have around 12 teeth combined, but they still manage to gum these tasty morsels down to a nub in no time!