TV
Sinead Butler
Jan 17, 2022
Julia Hartley-Brewer’s criticism of licence that funds the BBC has backfired spectacularly as people on Twitter have defended the fee by destroying her argument in a number of different ways.
The debate surrounding the BBC licence fee has arisen once again after the government announced a two-year freeze in the broadcaster’s funding, with plans to abolish the licence fee completely in 2027.
Culture secretary, Nadine Dorries said: “This licence fee announcement will be the last. The days of the elderly being threatened with prison sentences and bailiffs knocking on doors are over. Time now to discuss and debate new ways of funding, supporting and selling great British content.”
While BBC stars, Gary Lineker, Nish Kumar, Armando Iannucci, Michael Rosen, and Deborah Meaden have defended the broadcaster, talkRADIO host Julia Hartley-Brewer appears to have questioned whether the licence fee is good value for money.
Sign up to our free Indy100 weekly newsletter
In a tweet, she wrote: “I pay the BBC licence fee and these are the only services I ever use. Good value for money...?”
The tweet also includes an image of a table that has all the different BBC services and programmes, where all of them are crossed out except the services Hartley-Brewer says she uses, which are: BBC One, BBC Two, BBC iPlayer, BBC News, BBC Parliament, BBC Radio 4 and BBC Radio 5.
I pay the BBC licence fee and these are the only services I ever use. Good value for money...?🤷🏻♀️ https://t.co/435wmJGBrn— Julia Hartley-Brewer (@Julia Hartley-Brewer) 1642363093
But many were quick to point out how Hartley-Brewer’s argument fails when you apply it to different contexts.
While we pay a monthly fee for the internet, it would be pretty difficult to use/access every single part of the internet yet we still believe we get good value for money.
I PAY FOR BROADBAND ON A MONTHLY BASIS, YET I NEVER USE THE ENTIRETY OF THE INTERNET IS THIS VALUE FOR MONEY? NO T… https://t.co/fPqzCp7f5V— Sugar Horse (@Sugar Horse) 1642414060
Someone else applied this logic to our council tax, things would be a little different if we used Hartley-Brewer’s logic...
I pay the my council tax and these are the only services I ever use. Good value for money...?🤷♂️… https://t.co/kDUfqqRlDp— Sean Coleman (@Sean Coleman) 1642374979
As others also pointed out the flaw in only paying for what we use.
I pay my taxes and only used two schools, three hospitals and a tiny fraction of the roads… I want my money back fo… https://t.co/llmiN7FYeA— Nathaniel J Hall (@Nathaniel J Hall) 1642412289
“I pay road tax on my car and these are the only roads I ever use. Good value for money?” https://t.co/OY5FdMfXl2— George Peretz QC (@George Peretz QC) 1642407141
You think that's bad... 5% of my council tax bill goes on the fire service and so far my house hasn't been burnt do… https://t.co/vQVoDFuSCX— Morphobraincreature (@Morphobraincreature) 1642403709
As comedian Rosie Jones joked, does this mean we’ve been wasting our money on confectionary if we only eat our favourites from a box of chocolates?
I paid for a tin of Celebrations at Christmas and I only ate the Snickers, Mars, Bounties, Milky Ways, Galaxy Milks… https://t.co/RRpwPXSXW2— Rosie Jones (@Rosie Jones) 1642380329
How about when we use other facilities such as a swimming pool?
When I go to the swimming pool I only ever use one lane out of eight. So why do I have to pay £4 and not just 50p. https://t.co/34hDdfXwQL— Declan Lawn (@Declan Lawn) 1642405649
Meanwhile, someone else was able to provide the perfect analogy of a bus service to explain why the BBC is beneficial for us all, even if we don’t watch every single program.
The answer to your question is ‘Yes.’ If it helps, think of the BBC as a bus service. You get on and off at your st… https://t.co/pXvHZiNB1F— Nicholas Pegg (@Nicholas Pegg) 1642380476
When breaking down the cost of the £159 licence fee, it equates to the bargain price of just 43p per day to access all of these services as plenty of people have highlighted in this debate.
@JuliaHB1 43p a day to use all of that? Yes I'd honestly say that was great value.— Otto English (@Otto English) 1642403442
@JuliaHB1 For 43p a day, yes I'd say that's great value for those valuable resources— Kris Griffiths (@Kris Griffiths) 1642363280
It’s a good point, getting BBC One, Two & Radios 4 & 5Live plus dedicated channels for News and Parliament along wi… https://t.co/Aeh3bFRcA3— Matt Arnold (@Matt Arnold) 1642404874
@JuliaHB1 Yes, Julia, 43p a day for access to seven media outlets is a bargain. Not to mention you probably see BBC… https://t.co/4JbAuykiYi— Callum (@Callum) 1642408776
One person also noted we’re not just paying the fee for ourselves, but also for the benefit of others so we all win.
Imagine! Paying things for the mutual benefit of others. https://t.co/IX9KCTqo31— Nat Guest (@Nat Guest) 1642404549
When applying this argument to getting the money’s worth out of a festival ticket - it would certainly make for an intense experience.
Why should I pay so much for a festival ticket if I don’t want to see all 350+ acts on the bill? #SaveOurBBC https://t.co/0Pthc0wSVs— Drowned in Sound ⚓️ (@Drowned in Sound ⚓️) 1642400496
While others pointed out that Hartley-Brewer has benefitted from the BBC since she has appeared as a guest on BBC One’s Question Time - and the fact that her profile picture is actually from one of her appearances on the programme.
BBC Services would have been responsible for using funds from the license fee to pay your invoice for appearing on… https://t.co/xUhOTXNCC9— Stephen Grant (@Stephen Grant) 1642402484
BBC Question Time paid for your profile picture https://t.co/gwo2g7fJcd— J Λ M Ξ S (@J Λ M Ξ S) 1642410499
Some noted how people choose to pay for a Netflix subscription but due to its never-ending catalogue, people wouldn’t be getting their money’s worth if Hartley-Brewer’s argument was applied here.
lol imagine if you made the same graphic and crossed out every weird and wonderful show you don’t watch on Netflix.… https://t.co/GqfVTJ3guR— Toby Forster (@Toby Forster) 1642403911
Totally agree. But then again if I did a similar audit of content on Netflix and Amazon Prime, the carnage of cro… https://t.co/BRNJjf6vFm— Alex Phillips (@Alex Phillips) 1642409351
Something tells us this BBC licence debate is going away anytime soon.
Top 100
The Conversation (0)
x