In this year where nothing has gone according to plan, there has been one reliable constant: memes.
If we were to crown one meme that has ruled 2020, the winner has to be the Sue Sylvester meme.
But what exactly is the Sue Sylvester meme?
The meme itself is a screenshot of Jane Lynch as Sue Sylvester in Glee as she says that she’s “going to create an environment that is so toxic”. The scene comes from the seventh episode of the show’s first season in which Sue vows to destroy the school glee club by sowing divisions in the team, hence the “toxic environment”.
It’s not a particularly memorable moment in a show that’s littered with some of the most outrageous plot lines to have graced television, but it probably speaks to the very toxic environment we’re living in now in a way that has surprisingly resonated with social media users stuck at home and stuck online.
How did it become popular?
According to Know Your Meme, the meme began circulating in its original form in July with one user’s very meta take on the quote.
sue sylvester when she's going to create an environment that is so toxic https://t.co/RWtsZFpRv6— elmo 🌿 (@elmo 🌿) 1593312334
Afterwards, it quickly gained traction as users used the screenshot to describe a multitude of bad environments.
ryan murphy choosing the glee cast members https://t.co/BdHfVS0lW4— matt (@matt) 1593384960
the inventor of plastic: https://t.co/6hucFpwqZL— giabucchi (@giabucchi) 1593632484
It then grew into an entirely different beast as different variations on the format emerged, with users tweaking the quote to fit their own jokes.
My mom on Facebook https://t.co/awgj7dFX7J— J (@J) 1606517101
Romulus circa 753BCE: https://t.co/Og8BuHZWBU— the thicc husband & father (@the thicc husband & father) 1606604004
my anxiety: https://t.co/J85vORJhBm— priya formerly from the DMs (@priya formerly from the DMs) 1605913869
Strangely, the format has longevity no one could anticipate, inspiring memes still to this day. Considering that a life cycle of a meme tends to be pretty short, a meme remaining popular for almost half a year is unheard of.
would love to read an analysis of why the hell the sue sylvester meme has managed to be the defining meme of 2020??… https://t.co/0AVG8vNTVv— grace barber-plentie (@grace barber-plentie) 1606729927
As the meme started taking off in popularity once again this month, it also inspired some backlash. Some are just tired of seeing a dozen iterations of the same format every day.
Me, to the Sue Sylvester memes https://t.co/28xk9r3ezv— Chris Schleicher (@Chris Schleicher) 1606622251
And as writer and self-proclaimed “lover of memes” Stan Cross argued, changing almost all of the words in the original screenshot does not make it a meme.
this 'meme' of the woman from glee where people change almost every single aspect of what she said apart from the w… https://t.co/1zCTcA6ESK— Stan Account (@Stan Account) 1606652481
To be fair, there are certain (hilarious) posts out there that lose almost all of the original context.
I actually love how there are now zero rules to the Sue Sylvester meme 🤣 https://t.co/DwXoWQZeAf— WayneDavid (@WayneDavid) 1606683591
scottish people when they agree: https://t.co/757BPzgsUy— Tom (@Tom) 1606595637
But as one user pointed out, these deconstructionist memes resemble the Gossip Girl meme from earlier this year, a trend that went so abstract it’s impossible to explain.
the way these sue sylvester memes are the gossip girl ones but evolved https://t.co/kJvE7fiTdk— val (@val) 1606590575
Memes are an unpredictable phenomena that can’t really be explained, but the fact that the meme can be edited to adapt to any joke and situation is probably why it has lasted for so long. Plus, people just think it’s funny. Isn’t that all you need from a meme anyway?
In the midst of the unpredictable, knowing I’m going to continue seeing that Sue Sylvester meme every five minutes… https://t.co/ZWGwPk2ToB— matt horwood (@matt horwood) 1606742948
With a meme that gives people some semblance of joy, maybe the environment isn’t so toxic after all.