Sinead Butler
Jan 23, 2022
Independent
When it became clear that Tonga may spend a month without internet cable after a recent volcanic eruption and tsunami, Elon Musk was on hand, offering to get it back up and running with his SpaceX Starlink - but then backtracked on the offer minutes later on Twitter.
As a result of the volcano eruption on January 15th, which was 500 times more powerful than an atomic bomb, a 7.4 magnitude earthquake hit the Pacific Island and caused a tsunami, knocking out the country's telecommunication networks.
On Wednesday, phones were reconnected but until the undersea cable gets fixed after being severed from the recent natural disaster, the people of Tonga remain without internet.
Though billionaire Elon Musk has since offered to help (albeit, an offer that stood for a few minutes before being backpedalled).
In a tweet, responding to a Reuter's article about the currently limited internet access in the country, Musk questioned whether the Tongan people thought it was important for Space X to send over some of their Starlink satellites to the island in order to provide them with internet access through laser links.
He asked: "Could people from Tonga let us know if it is important for SpaceX to send over Starlink terminals."
Could people from Tonga let us know if it is important for SpaceX to send over Starlink terminals?— Elon Musk (@Elon Musk) 1642748800
However, there was an issue with this which caused Musk to make a rapid U-turn.
Soon after he made the offer, the billionaire quickly replied to a letter addressed to him from New Zealand MP Shane Reti who urged him to contribute his Starlink to the reconnection effort.
Sign up to our free Indy100 weekly newsletter
"This is a hard thing for us to do right now, as we don’t have enough satellites with laser links and there are already geo sats that serve the Tonga region. That is why I’m asking for clear confirmation," he tweeted.
Basically, the geo satellites which are used for TV, radio, etc and also forecasting the weather are already over the island and so there's not enough space for Musk to move his Starlink terminals over there too.
This is a hard thing for us to do right now, as we don\u2019t have enough satellites with laser links and there are already geo sats that serve the Tonga region. That is why I\u2019m asking for clear confirmation.— Elon Musk (@Elon Musk) 1642749248
People on Twitter appear divided over the interaction, with some praising the Space X CEO for being upfront within minutes of whether he could realistically help Tonga out, while other people believe Reti and others have called Musk's bluff and also pointed out while Musk may not be able to help with the country's internet problem, he could provide aid in other areas such as providing food and water to those affected.
Tonga: whatever, please, just help!\nElon: This is pretty hard for me to do right now on account of there being no such thing, but it's a fucking cool idea\nTechbros: [slurp, slurp]https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1484424055071641602\u00a0\u2026— Ben Torkington (@Ben Torkington) 1642887973
I think the people of Tonga would rather have construction equipment, water filters, food and toilet paper. Why try to act like the internet is their most important essential? Elon acts like a 50yr old with a 5yr old\u2019s mentality.— Daemujinn (@Daemujinn) 1642778330
People so quick to judge Elon when all he does is try to help https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1484424055071641602\u00a0\u2026— The Doge Father III (@The Doge Father III) 1642767711
I never give up - Elon's words. If there is even the slightest chance, they will work on it. Don't be unfair, support!https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1484424055071641602\u00a0\u2026— Rebalance (@Rebalance) 1642883649
Elon offering help just to immediately set a situationally very higher bar to provide that help feels very on brandhttps://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1484424055071641602\u00a0\u2026— Jacob Mauren (@Jacob Mauren) 1642750231
We know you don\u2019t do this for recognition but tip of the hat for always trying to do the right thing— tes.3m.21 (@tes.3m.21) 1642750473
How are they meant to communicate that they need help when their tower has been damaged and most of the island is with out cable internet /commuicationhttps://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1484424055071641602\u00a0\u2026— Simon c (@Simon c) 1642921735
Best place for clear confirmation is obviously twitter.https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1484424055071641602\u00a0\u2026— Unwashed Mass (@Unwashed Mass) 1642759062
Top 100
The Conversation (0)