Politics
Kate Plummer
Jun 23, 2022
Indy
When technology minister Chris Philp trotted down to parliament to debate the government's online safety bill this week, he probably was prepared to field questions about potential amendments, tweaks and issues - but not dick pics.
But that is exactly what happened, when discussing tightening amendments to stop cyber-flashing, the minister was asked if he had ever received an unsolicited photo of a penis.
Philp had been talking about striking "a balance" and thinking about intent when people exchange intimate images when Labour MP Alex Davies-Jones asked: "Has the minister ever received a dick pic?"
"Is that a rhetorical question?" Philp replied, to which Davies-Jones said "no", causing Philp to reveal he hadn't received one.
"So he cannot possibly know how it feels to receive one," Davies-Jones replied. "I appreciate the comments that he is trying to make, and that this is a fine balance, but I do see this specific issue of sending a photograph or film of genitals as black and white: they are sent either with or without consent. It is as simple as that."
Sign up to our free Indy100 weekly newsletter
Philp said people may "misjudge" situations and could "essentially by accident" commit an offence. "If we replace the word 'intent' with 'without consent', the risk is that someone who does something essentially by accident will have committed a criminal offence," he said.
The bill is making its way through parliament and includes a clause that could see people serve a maximum sentence of two years in prison if they send unsolicited sexual images.
When it was announced, culture secretary Nadine Dorries said: "The forthcoming Online Safety Bill will force tech companies to stop their platforms being used to commit vile acts of cyber flashing. We are bringing the full weight on individuals who perpetrate this awful behaviour."
But some think it doesn't go far enough, as illustrated by the discussion in parliament. After the debate, Davies-Jones tweeted:
\u201cQuite the exchange in Bill committee \ud83d\udc40\ud83c\udf46\ud83d\udcf7\n\nBut the point remains that the new (and welcome) Cyber flashing offence in the Online Safety Bill will only bring true, meaningful change if it\u2019s based on consent rather than intent.\n\nThe Bill MUST go further to protect women & girls!\u201d— Alex Davies-Jones MP (@Alex Davies-Jones MP) 1655976479
Never a dull moment in Westminster.
Have your say in our news democracy. Click the upvote icon at the top of the page to help raise this article through the indy100 rankings.
Top 100
The Conversation (0)