Yasemin Craggs Mersinoglu
Jan 06, 2021
Lucas Dawson/Getty Images
Gendered marketing and the sale of “feminine” and “masculine” products has been called out for being outdated for a while, with some blaming toxic societal norms for their continuation.
Photographer Jonathan Ivan set off a new debate on social media after tweeting about the brand War Paint, which sells makeup for men.
He tweeted: “Masculinity is so fragile they have to call an eye concealer War Paint.”
Ivan was referring to the label avoiding the term makeup, in what he appeared to perceive as an effort to subvert prejudice against men using beauty products.
Fragile masculinity is loosely defined as insecurity felt by men who believe they do not meet cultural standards of manhood and subsequently may overcompensate their behaviour in an attempt to restore this status.
The avoidance of “feminine” connotations associated with cosmetics may have also led War Paint to choose all-black packaging for the goods.
However, the company states its aim is to “break the stigma that makeup is solely for women” and make men “feel comfortable to shout about wearing makeup”.
Its product line includes concealer, tinted moisturiser, anti-shine powder, bronzer and brow gel.
Social media users shared their thoughts on the brand, with some agreeing with Ivan.
@jonathanivan @tentativelyrics Lmao i feel like it'd make more sense to name women's makeup war paint cuz my god we… https://t.co/kGy41xgtvl— Harini (@Harini) 1609849548
@jonathanivan for anybody interested in a *very* informative way, we looked at this in an advertising course i took… https://t.co/EugWB49BUh— vi 🌅 (@vi 🌅) 1609843518
@jonathanivan SNL did this sketch a year ago lol. https://t.co/Hd7FN34JeN— Kali Kailani (@Kali Kailani) 1609871119
It’s also not the first time cosmetics have been marketed differently to men.
@jonathanivan Died out years ago but here you go, Alpha Nail https://t.co/neG5NXPSVa— j (@j) 1609848702
I can think of nothing more fragile than this https://t.co/wRnePUFDnY https://t.co/3MeCnIVpgY— LumberJack Larson 🌲 (@LumberJack Larson 🌲) 1609864806
However, others supported the company’s choices.
@jonathanivan While I understand, it’s a way to ease them into this, and essentially break down a few stereotypes,… https://t.co/vLvMVzexh9— 𝕍 𝙀 𝙂 𝙀 𝙏 𝘼 (@𝕍 𝙀 𝙂 𝙀 𝙏 𝘼) 1609855298
@jonathanivan @HelenaDiGiusti I think the name is made to attract more customers, because it is a striking name, I… https://t.co/qS1il4UeBn— Edd ✨ (@Edd ✨) 1609935801
Top 100
The Conversation (0)