Kate Plummer
Apr 20, 2021
Rex Features
Richard Dawkins has been stripped of an award following a row triggered by comments he made about trans people.
In a statement, the American Humanist Association Board (AHA) said they had “voted to withdraw” the biologist’s Humanist of the Year award, for making statements that “demean marginalised groups.”
The statement read: “Richard Dawkins has over the past several years accumulated a history of making statements that use the guise of scientific discourse to demean marginalised groups.
“His latest statement implies that the identities of transgender individuals are fraudulent, while also simultaneously attacking Black identity as one that can be assumed when convenient. His subsequent attempts at clarification are inadequate and convey neither sensitivity nor sincerity.”
While AHA did not specify what statement they were referring to, it seems likely they are referring to an incident that took place earlier this month.
Read more:
- Keir Starmer has perfect response after a confrontation with pub landlord spreading misinformation
- Video of shelter dog reacting to being adopted is 12 seconds of pure joy
- 38 of the funniest memes about the widely criticised European Super League
- A complete timeline of Lizzo’s drunken DM drama with Chris Evans
- The biggest coffee buying mistake that most people are making
Posting on Twitter, Dawkins sparked controversy after he compared transgender people to Rachel Dolezal – a white woman who infamously appropriated a Black identity while pursuing Black activism.
He tweeted:
In 2015, Rachel Dolezal, a white chapter president of NAACP, was vilified for identifying as Black. Some men choose… https://t.co/zCshd9kAcd— Richard Dawkins (@Richard Dawkins) 1618046412
In response, numerous people pointed out that his argument was far from nuanced, and that it was not possible to compare race and gender.
This is bad faith bc trans people and sociologists of race and tons of others clarify this conflation after Rebecca… https://t.co/vMRZehgYgc— Zoé (@Zoé) 1618189492
Small problem: trans people don’t really “choose” to transition. Furthermore, your understanding of gender identity… https://t.co/uaR3VDJkAq— J4ded (@J4ded) 1618141018
Now, AHA has weighed in and have removed his accolade.
The statement continued: “The AHA board has concluded that Richard Dawkins is no longer deserving of being honoured by the AHA, and has voted to withdraw, effective immediately, the 1996 Humanist of the Year award.”
Dawkins originally received the award in 1996 for his work as a science communicator. While he has continued to post on Twitter, he does not appeared to have responded to his award being stripped.
And it is not the first time he has made controversial comments about transgender people. Here are a couple:
Is trans woman a woman? Purely semantic. If you define by chromosomes, no. If by self-identification, yes. I call her "she" out of courtesy.— Richard Dawkins (@Richard Dawkins) 1445862899
Yes, I know it’s behind a paywall but it’s worth it. Superb article by Trevor Phillips on the oppressive nonsense t… https://t.co/A6WHk6u7WN— Richard Dawkins (@Richard Dawkins) 1604794731
Oh dear.
Top 100
The Conversation (0)